Best Musical To NOT WIN The Tony Award

What is the ‘Best Musical To NOT WIN The Tony Award?’ Each week, our readers picked the winners in head-to-head matchups until we narrowed down the field of 64 to just one ultimate selection.

Please share your thoughts with us on social media. Tell us why voted for your winners or what you think of our bracket seedings. Spread the word to your friends and fellow enthusiasts! And don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE to our weekly newsletter to get the latest on song playlists, special broadcasts, and new features.

Start Page | Round 1A | Round 1B | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Round 6

View the entire opening bracket in one graphic: » wide version » tall version.

CHAMPIONSHIP: 1. West Side Story vs 2. Gypsy (54-46)
CONSOLATION MATCH: 12. Ragtime vs 14. Come from Away (63-37)

1. West Side Story def. 12. Ragtime (67-33)
2. Gypsy def. 14. Come from Away (61-39)

A REGION:
1. West Side Story def. 8. Follies (58-42)

D REGION:
12. Ragtime def. 29. She Loves Me (59-41)

B REGION:
2. Gypsy def. 10. Chicago (61-39)

C REGION:
14. Come from Away def. 11. Into the Woods (56-44) ** UPSET! **

A REGION:
1. West Side Story def. 16. Dreamgirls (84-16)
8. Follies def. 56. Grand Hotel: The Musical (85-15)

D REGION:
29. She Loves Me def. 13. Wicked (51-49) ** UPSET! **
12. Ragtime def. 5. Mame (75-25) ** UPSET! **

B REGION:
2. Gypsy def. 18. Miss Saigon (83-17)
10. Chicago def. 7. Promises, Promises (75-25) ** UPSET! **

C REGION:
11. Into the Woods def. 6. Hair (82-18) ** UPSET! **
14. Come from Away def. 3. Oliver! (69-31) ** UPSET! **

A REGION:
1. West Side Story def. 33. Newsies (90-10)
8. Follies def. 40. Carnival! (88-12)
16. Dreamgirls def. 17. Next to Normal (90-1)
56. Grand Hotel: The Musical def. 41. Bells Are Ringing (66-34) ** UPSET! **

D REGION:
29. She Loves Me def. 4. Funny Girl (56-44) ** UPSET! **
5. Mame def. 37. The Full Monty (74-26)
13. Wicked def. 45. Mary Poppins (85-15)
12. Ragtime def. 44. The Scottsboro Boys (89-11)

B REGION:
2. Gypsy def. 34. The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas (91-9)
7. Promises, Promises def. 39. Once on This Island (55-45)
10. Chicago def. 23. On the Twentieth Century (79-21)
18. Miss Saigon def. 15. Parade (56-44) ** UPSET! **

C REGION:
3. Oliver! def. 30. Sweet Charity (55-45)
6. Hair def. 38. Falsettos (55-45)
11. Into the Woods vs 19. Sunday in the Park with George (65-35)
14. Come from Away vs 22. Me and My Girl (80-20)

B REGION
2. Gypsy def. 63. Passing Strange (98-2)
7. Promises, Promises def. 58. Little Me (72-28)
10. Chicago def. 55. The Secret Garden (78-22)
15. Parade def. 50. The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee (56-44)
18. Miss Saigon def. 47. Barnum (56-44)
23. On the Twentieth Century def. 42. Suffs (79-21) ** UPSET! **
39. Once on This Island def. 26. Aladdin (31-69) ** UPSET! **
34. The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas def. 31. No Strings (33-67) ** UPSET! **

C REGION
3. Oliver! vs 62. They’re Playing Our Song (73-27)
6. Hair vs 59. Pipe Dream (73-27)
11. Into the Woods vs 54. Jelly’s Last Jam (92-8)
14. Come from Away vs 51. Pacific Overtures (65-35)
19. Sunday in the Park with George vs 46. Urinetown (85-15)
22. Me and My Girl vs 43. The Who’s Tommy (55-45)
38. Falsettos def. 27. Beautiful: The Carole King Musical (26-74) ** UPSET! **
30. Sweet Charity vs 35. The Color Purple (88-12)

A REGION
1. West Side Story def. 64. Mamma Mia! (98-2)
8. Follies def. 57. The Rothschilds (98-2)
56. Grand Hotel: The Musical def. 9. Pippin (51-49) ** UPSET! **
16. Dreamgirls vs 49. Woman of the Year (73-27)
17. Next to Normal def. 48. My One and Only (57-43)
41. Bells Are Ringing def. 24. Beauty and the Beast (61-39) ** UPSET! **
40. Carnival! def. 25. Waitress (57-43) ** UPSET! **
33. Newsies def. 32. Matilda the Musical (58-42) ** UPSET! **

D REGION
4. Funny Girl def. 61. Zorba (76-24)
5. Mame def. 60. Golden Boy (96-4)
12. Ragtime def. 53. Grey Gardens (83-17)
13. Wicked def. 52. Mean Girls (89-11)
45. Mary Poppins def. 20. Grease (53-47) ** UPSET! **
44. The Scottsboro Boys def. 21. Titanic (62-38) ** UPSET! **
37. The Full Monty def. 28. An American in Paris (67-33) ** UPSET! **
29. She Loves Me def. 36. Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (90-10)

FULL SEEDINGS 1-64

Start Page | Round 1A | Round 1B | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Round 6